There are undoubtedly several geographical places around which the earth seems to rotate, and Afghanistan is one of them. Sometimes forgotten, sometimes the focus of attention, sometimes mythologized, Afghanistan is consequential.
Situated between the Iranian plateau and the Himalayan mountains, Afghanistan has long stood at the crossroads of cultural, economic, and political forces. Its position along ancient trade routes such as the Silk Road made it a meeting point for commodities and ideas from Asia, the Middle East, and beyond. As a result, Afghanistan became a vibrant center of cultural exchange, where religions such as Buddhism and Islam—and artistic and intellectual traditions—flourished.
At the same time, this strategic location made Afghanistan a perpetual object of political ambition. For centuries, empires and foreign powers sought to control its mountain passes and trade corridors. External conquerors—from Darius I, Alexander the Great, and Genghis Khan to the Soviets, British, and Americans—tried to dominate it, but none succeeded in holding it permanently. This struggle for control, driven by both foreign invaders and internal factions, has shaped Afghanistan’s complex and turbulent history.
Yet as much as Afghanistan has been a site of crossroads, resistance, and resilience, it has also been a place from which countless people have fled to escape persecution, disaster, and scarcity. Since the UN began tracking displacement, Afghans have constituted one of the world’s largest and most protracted displaced populations. While most have taken refuge in neighboring Iran and Pakistan – countries that now deport them in large numbers – others live in India, Europe, the United States, and beyond. Some have been in exile for over four decades, making the notion of “home” almost unimaginable.
Afghanistan’s strategic location has long invited conquest, but in more recent decades, the “war on terror” and the rhetoric of “saving women” have served as new imperial justifications. Only days after 9/11, the United States invaded Afghanistan in pursuit of Osama bin Laden. While the primary motive was retribution for Al-Qaeda’s attack on U.S. soil, Afghan women’s rights and freedoms were used by the U.S. administration to garner popular support. What is often forgotten is that during the 1970s, Afghan women were active and visible in numerous spheres of public life. That period was not an anomaly but an opening toward the kind of society many Afghans have long desired – one not confined by theocratic despotism. Furthermore, it was local reform, not foreign intervention, that made these gains for women possible.
The U.S. presence initially pushed the Taliban into retreat, and ten years later, bin Laden was killed. During this period, some women regained access to education and other basic rights. But when the U.S. and the Taliban negotiated the withdrawal of troops through the 2020 Doha Agreement, women were excluded from the talks. It should come as no surprise, then, that women’s rights practically disappeared soon after the Taliban’s return. Did Afghan women ever really matter?
The Taliban’s 2021 takeover of Afghanistan once again underscored a familiar lesson: the futility of using military might to enforce change. The United States’ hasty and chaotic retreat mirrored that of its Cold War rival, the Soviet Union. The manner of the retreat – in which countless Afghan fighters and aides who fought side by side with Americans were left behind – was, therefore, less a surprise than an inevitability.
For South Asians, however, such sudden abandonment was nothing new. The British, too, had swiftly abandoned their crown jewel – the Indian subcontinent, with its kingdoms, treasures, and cultural wealth – almost overnight, partitioning that vast and diverse land by semi-arbitrary religious measures. That departure in 1947 set the stage for horror and tragedy, resulting in the largest migration in human history and a communal bloodbath, as Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs unleashed terror upon one another. The subcontinent never recovered from the trauma of Partition-induced migration, and the Afghan tragedy feels like an echo of that trauma – albeit under a different guise and with different occupiers.
The Taliban’s return to power has again placed the politics of one of the world’s most populous regions on a knife’s edge. As the Taliban struggle to govern, they have grown increasingly desperate for international aid and recognition. In pursuit of legitimacy, they have formed unlikely connections with Modi’s India and even their former foes in Russia, which has already extended official recognition. India, after its most recent border clashes with Pakistan, sees in the Taliban an opportunity to apply pressure on its rival. While Modi’s India demonizes its own Muslim citizens as terrorists and anti-nationals, creating the perfect pretext for stripping them of citizenship, it simultaneously courts a radical Islamist group to destabilize Pakistan.
Sensing danger, Pakistan has launched military operations along its border with Afghanistan, resulting in civilian casualties on both sides. Alarmingly, since 2023, Pakistan has also forcibly deported nearly a million Afghan refugees, compounding the suffering of an already traumatized population.
The presence of a theocratic despotism on the frontier also bodes ill for South Asian women, who continue to struggle for equality and equity. Hardline Islamists from Bangladesh have traveled to Kabul to meet Taliban officials, perhaps seeking guidance on how to establish another form of gender apartheid in South Asia. Meanwhile, disillusioned Muslim youths across the region – frustrated by corruption, inequality, and the failures of their own governments – are making pilgrimages to Afghanistan, swelling the ranks of extremist groups allied with or opposed to the Taliban. Upon returning home, these radicalized youths bring further instability.
Ordinary Afghans find themselves trapped in this tangled web of hypocrisy, treachery, and shifting alliances—all of which inflict more violence and trauma, forcing them to seek refuge in nations that dehumanize them and treat them as burdens.
War and aggression have never been effective means of cultivating democracy, tolerance, responsibility, or peace. Democratic values can only take root when the political power of local people is respected; when their civilization and culture are valued; and when poverty is reduced, employment expanded, and education made accessible. Stable societies depend on trust, respect for difference, and a willingness to listen and compromise for the greater good. External forces—whether the USSR, the U.S., India, or Pakistan—have modeled none of these principles. They intervene and “uplift” only for their own benefit. They abandon as soon as the loss outweighs the cost, never counting the impact their presence and departure have had on the people they claimed to protect.
Afghanistan’s long history of interference and conflict continues to shape the lives of those forced to flee. In exile, Afghans carry the weight of these histories alongside the resilience that defines their homeland. In their displacement, they preserve fragments of memory, culture, and belonging, transforming exile into both a form of survival and a burden. This issue of Shuddhashar FreeVoice centers on Afghan experiences of exile.

Pingback: Cartographier nos histoires à raconter – Entre les lignes entre les mots