A Reading of Palestinian Memes as Counter-Discourse under Colonialism and Censorship

From Carnival to Algorithm: A Reading of Palestinian Memes as Counter-Discourse under Colonialism and Censorship

Share this:

Memes are not merely publishable content, but a constantly evolving space of resistance, and thus the last remaining form of freedom in a time when the Palestinian cause is being silently erased.

This world may seem imaginary, but after the revolution in technology, social media, and artificial intelligence, it has become undeniably real. The world is run behind phone screens and in cramped, dark rooms. Control over humanity doesn’t begin with violence, murder, or even brutal massacres, but rather with the visual organization of everything. Wars are waged through screens, and genocide is reproduced as a “security incident,” reducing catastrophe to neutral headlines.

The masses are forced to watch silently without any resistance, as if watching a 21st-century Hollywood film. Among the most popular Hollywood films , The Hunger Games comes to mind, not to alleviate the harshness of the Palestinian reality, nor as a direct moral comparison between Gaza and the film, but rather as a tool for deconstructing the mechanisms of visual power. It reveals an authoritarian logic that we have been living with for nearly two years since the genocidal war on Gaza.

Colonial powers and authoritarian forces in the East and West have not been content with controlling the masses through violence alone but have also organized this violence visually. In the occupied territories, the occupying state and its army have not only subjected the public, whether in Israel/Palestine or throughout the world, to watching the killing of Palestinians not as a crime, but as a carefully orchestrated and broadcast public event. They do not stop at punishing Palestinians or those who stand in solidarity with them but also punish anyone who refuses to watch in silence.

However, this refusal does not begin with political rhetoric, but with an image, a gesture, or a small symbol that can be repeated and disseminated, becoming a signal for the beginning of resistance against authoritarian authorities — a resistance that cannot be eradicated or contained.

This world may seem a fantasy, but in The Hunger Games, the three-finger salute signalled the start of a rebellion. Similarly, Palestinian memes like watermelons (referring to the Palestinian flag), cartoon images of children and women being killed in full view of the world, anthems of resistance for Palestine, the traditional Palestinian dabke dance (a symbol of life), and the scrambled writing containing symbols to circumvent censorship and algorithms — all these memes, despite their visual poverty, are politically charged. They recur and spread rapidly as symbolic acts of resistance during the genocide in Gaza. They do so not through direct confrontation, but by exposing the authority and stripping it of its control.

They cannot stop the violence, but they disrupt the narrative of these authoritarian powers and unsettle the system of spectacle that seeks to transform the victim into mere content. The question is no longer what happened, but who allowed the image to be seen. The story isn’t about control through violence, but about managing that violence. In the age of algorithms, reality is reproduced and managed through that matrix.

In that world, violence isn’t measured by the number of dead, but by the number of views. In Gaza, it wasn’t just the relentless bombing, killing, and starvation; there was a complete system for managing perception, for organizing empathy, for controlling the language allowed to describe what was happening.

In this world, words are besieged like cities, and genocide is reproduced as a security event, forcing the collective mind to watch as a silent witness. Here, Palestinian memes emerge not as a fleeting cultural product or entertainment, but as a rebellious political act, a collective response to rejecting spectatorship and silence, as if it were a means of reclaiming a minimum of sovereignty over the narrative in the face of systematic killing and forced starvation.

The Palestinian memes that spread with incredible speed, whether from Palestinians themselves or from supporters of Palestinian rights worldwide, can be interpreted as not merely demonstrations and protests the genocide in Gaza, but as a reassertion of control over the narrative in the face of colonialism and tyranny.

What is happening in Palestine is not an exception, but rather a highly concentrated model unprecedented in the world, not only in territories colonized by traditional means, but also among oppressed peoples controlled by authoritarian powers and dictatorships. From Latin America to South Africa, from Kashmir to the indigenous populations of Canada and Australia, these communities today, in a digitally dominated world, are using the same tools of resistance: memes, short videos, satire, and coded language.

These memes are a digital extension of a long history of cultural resistance through diverse means, from carnivals and revolutionary posters to poetry, literature, folk songs, and underground music, all the way to memes born on mobile phones under bombardment, during displacement, and during periods of forced starvation. The same idea is repeated and spreads rapidly. While images, news, and headlines are censored, they are reproduced, repeated, and disseminated through artificial intelligence and social media channels, including images, cartoons, comics, clips, and animated films.

This article is not purely academic; perhaps it is a form of resistance, one of the Palestinian memes that attempts to approach Palestinian digital art not as an immediate reaction to what happened and is still happening in Gaza and the West Bank in terms of systematic killing, forced displacement, and starvation, but as a counter-discourse that takes shape within the structure of colonial powers and their surveillance tools, where genocide intersects with algorithms, occupation with social media networks, and military censorship with policies of “sensitive content,” or incitement to terrorism and intimidation, or unsuitable for a large audience.

Digital Art and Memes as Symbolic Resistance

Based on Bakhtin’s approaches to carnival and the subversion of hierarchies (1984), Michel Foucault’s exploration of the mechanisms of power and censorship (1972), and Lemor Schiffman’s studies on digital culture (2014), Palestinian memes, despite their fragility, are a tool of resistance. They represent an act, a living testimony, a collective memory, and even an existential challenge in an era where the Palestinian voice and narrative are meant to be silently erased.

Here, digital art and memes are not merely expressions of public sentiment or fleeting forms of entertainment that quickly gain traction and disappear as intended. Rather, they have emerged in an age of censorship and the commodification of discourse, becoming among the most symbolic and effective tools of resistance. In the case of the genocide being perpetrated against Palestinians in Gaza, they have appeared as an interwoven and complex space where politics intersects with art, satire with protest, and playful exposure of power.

The power of the meme lies in its marginality. It requires no institutions, funding, or methodologies, and it bypasses official cultural channels. It doesn’t need elites to promote it; it is born in the digital space, spreads horizontally, and constantly evolves. It is not bound by the laws, molds, or theories of traditional art.

These characteristics are what make it a threat to authority, because it undermines its monopoly on narrative, restoring official voices and images in oppressive contexts to their original, truthful form, and redirecting the original narrative without containing or controlling it. The meme functions as a convoluted language that says what cannot be said directly, imbuing jokes and images with a political charge that is difficult to criminalize without exposing the fragility of authority itself.

In this context, meme production is not a retreat from reality, but rather a tool for deconstructing it, exposing it through exaggeration and satire and reveal the contradictions of what is meant to be spectacled. Digital memes have revived the traditions of the carnival, as described by Bakhtin, by inverting the pyramid, dismantling the aura of authority, and transforming the political sacred into a subject of ridicule that undermines the logic of obedience and silent spectatorship.

The meme also subverts the notion of the original artwork, the idea of ​​individuality, signature, ownership, and permanence, becoming an unfinished and reproducible version. Thus, the audience itself becomes a partner in the production of this art, not merely a recipient, and the creative process transforms into a cumulative act of resistance against authority itself.

The art of memes faces a fierce battle in the digital space between its desire for freedom and its resistance to containment or control, and its dependence on the digital structure produced by the very authority that controls it. Algorithmic censorship imposes deletions and restrictions, rearranging what is seen and what is not. Despite this, memes, especially those opposing colonial and authoritarian powers, remain akin to a popular archive of anger and memory — just as graffiti played a crucial role in preserving collective memory during the modern revolutions, from Crimea and the Balkans to the Arab region.

What is happening in Palestine is not an exception, but rather a highly concentrated model unprecedented in the world, not only in territories colonized by traditional means, but also among oppressed peoples controlled by authoritarian powers and dictatorships. From Latin America to South Africa, from Kashmir to the indigenous populations of Canada and Australia, these communities today, in a digitally dominated world, are using the same tools of resistance: memes, short videos, satire, and coded language.

The Palestinian Meme Against Censorship and Colonialism

In his book, The Right to Look: A Counterhistory of Visuality, Nicholas Mirzoff explains that the dominant power operates through the visual system, determining what is seen and how it is seen (2011). This is the situation in Palestine, where images are often produced from outside through cameras, military data, and social media platform algorithms that control what is published and how it is published, what is shown and what is hidden.

In response, memes emerge as a counter-response, re-employing images and narratives, deconstructing headlines and news, and transforming the published material from silent documentation into a new educational or cognitive language. In the Palestinian context, the killing does not stop at targeting bodies, living or dead, but extends to language.

The Palestinian narrative has been subjected for decades to replacement, alteration, erasure, demonization, and distortion. Resistance is transformed into terrorism, the martyr into a victim, colonialism into a land without a people, and Palestine itself is always under suspicion.

Palestinians themselves are always considered criminals, and even fetuses and children in their mothers’ wombs are potential future criminals. In this climate, digital art ceases to be an aesthetic or artistic choice and becomes a strategy of resistance and existential defense; it continues to exist within a densely controlled, erasing environment.

The Palestinian meme becomes not a source of self-deprecation or self-venting, but rather a tool for deconstructing violence itself. It reveals how genocide can be presented as ordinary news or reduced to a “complex situation” or “complex conflict.” In a global meme, it paints a picture of a world sitting calmly while devastation surrounds it everywhere.

This is not an image for laughter or ridicule, but rather one that exposes the moral paradox upon which the dominant discourse rests. Here, ridicule transforms into condemnation, and when it is repeated, naming the devastation as Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, and Iran, the repetition becomes a scandalous act. When phrases like “the right to self-defense” are attached to images of children under rubble, the official discourse is exposed, and Western media terms like neutrality and objectivity are revealed as systems of justification, not truth.

During the genocidal war on Gaza, various forms of memes were produced and widely disseminated. Some reused familiar international memes with altered captions, initially to circumvent censorship and utilize the same visual imagery ingrained in the Western collective consciousness, thus avoiding immediate rejection or deletion. A prime example was the re-application of the “This Is Fine” meme — a dog sitting calmly amidst a fire. In the Palestinian version, the fire was replaced with bombardment and smoke.

The dog is sitting calmly amidst a fire. In the Palestinian version, the flames were replaced with bombardment, smoke, and Western news headlines describing massacres as mere “events.” The dog tells us it’s fine. Here, the meme wasn’t meant to be satirical but rather to expose the normalization of violence, leaving us to question the international media: how can the world appear fine while Gaza burns?

The most important and powerful meme was the deconstruction of the sacred phrase launched by the occupying state and subsequently promoted in the media: “Israel Has the Right to Defend Itself.”

One of the most deconstructed phrases in Palestinian memes is the ready-made Western phrase: “Israel has the right to defend itself.” The phrase appeared repeatedly over many images, including pictures of children under rubble, destroyed neighborhoods, maps in which Gaza is gradually erased, tents of displaced people being burned as a result of continuous bombing, churches, hospitals, and schools that house hundreds and thousands of women, children, and wounded people being destroyed. Here, the images become an exposure of the phrase and the written phrase.

Palestinian map memes are a tool of resistance against visual erasure. They have spread during the past two years every time the population is displaced from cities that are completely or partially destroyed, as happened in northern Gaza and Rafah at times, and in all the projects launched by the colonial powers regarding the displacement of the population of Gaza.

The “shrinking map” of Palestine has presented an intense visual narrative of settler colonialism for decades, bypassing all political speeches and all international resolutions that are not implemented, and dismantling the Zionist narrative about Palestine and the Palestinians and the theft of the lands or areas of the Palestinian state.

Thus, map memes performed important functions, including visually documenting colonialism on the one hand, and dismantling the narrative of “conflict or dispute” and replacing it with a narrative of “theft and continuous appropriation”.

During the repeated attacks on Gaza, many hashtags were used, the most famous of which was #GazaUnderAttack, as a kind of digital documentation of events in the face of censorship erasure. These hashtags were considered global memes against the media and digital hegemony of the occupation and colonial powers.

These hashtags were accompanied by images of the bombing and Western media comments, short comics documenting the events but evading algorithms, clips about the difficult life that Palestinians live, about the power and water cuts and the systematic starvation, and they worked as an immediate popular archive in the face of the Western media, which deliberately shirks in conveying the news or changes the narrative and makes it cold and fatalistic news.

 

 

There are forms of digital art that have used Palestinian memes, but they don’t employ satire or expose the contradictions between the dominant colonial discourse and the lived reality. Instead, they use visual memes to document the tragedy of children, such as the animated film “Hind Rajab,” which uses sound and symbols rather than direct scenes to circumvent censorship and challenge the occupation’s narrative used to justify this tragedy. This contributes to the formation of a collective memory that preserves the Palestinian right to be seen and recognized.

Despite the limited production of animated memes about the events, other digital forms inspired by the stories of children who have been subjected to all forms of killing, bombing, and systematic starvation have emerged. These include drawings, cartoon symbols, and AI content that serve as icons. These icons don’t depict violence in the images or scenes themselves but rather are used in informational publications that encourage solidarity, urge accountability in the face of the war machine and censorship, and expose the colonial narrative.

 

Just as artificial intelligence was used in the war of extermination on Gaza, Palestinian activists and their supporters were able to use artificial intelligence techniques to confront colonial hegemony. They created memes and political images that aimed to break this monopoly on visual discourse. These spread rapidly across digital platforms and even forced Western media to discuss and analyze them.

The most widespread of these was the “All Eyes on Rafah” image campaign, which showed Palestinian tents barricaded with the phrase “All eyes on Rafah” It was shared more than 47 million times on Instagram, TikTok, and X platform within days after the devastating bombing of Rafah. Then began the journey of generating images and videos using artificial intelligence tools, achieving circumvention, evasion, and bypassing all forms of censorship and algorithms that developed methods of deletion and erasure in the face of this rapid viral spread.

Although the AI-generated visual content did not reflect real images of the war in Gaza, it created a powerful symbolic space to express solidarity with the Palestinian people and quickly penetrated the digital space, easily bypassing algorithmic censorship.

 

 

Returning to the film *The Hunger Games* and its three-finger salute as a rebellious meme rejecting hegemony, the Palestinian memes we mentioned in our article—which are merely illustrative examples—embody the spirit of digital resistance: symbols, images, and videos, small yet powerfully capable of penetrating censorship and unsettling the human conscience in the face of colonial hegemony and resisting the enforced silence imposed by those powers.

These powers attempt with all their might to control and dominate forms of popular resistance, containing and re-exporting them after emptying them of their content through trivialization and commodification, as happened with popular carnivals, underground music, graffiti, folk dances, posters, and flyers.

The danger lies not in the colonial powers’ or authorities’ containment of this meme art due to its fragility, but rather in transforming massacres into satirical material and trivializing them to the point of normalizing and consuming pain. This is where the awareness and creativity of digital activists become crucial.

Memes are not merely publishable content, but a constantly evolving space of resistance, and thus the last remaining form of freedom in a time when the Palestinian cause is being silently erased. We must keep the ethical question at the forefront of our minds, for it is the sole compass guiding our humanity: How can we laugh without betraying the victims? How can we mock without diminishing the gravity of the crime?

 

Works cited:

  1. Bakhtin, M. (1984). Rabelais and His World. Indiana University Press.
  2. Foucault, M. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge. Pantheon Books
  3. Wolfe, P. (2006). “Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native.” Journal of Genocide Research
  4. Shifman, L. (2014). Memes in Digital Culture. MIT Press.
  5. Butler, J. (2009). Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? Verso
  6. Mirzoeff, N. (2011). The Right to Look. Duke University Press
  7. Fanon, F. (1963). The Wretched of the Earth. Grove Press
  8. Gillespie, T. (2018). Custodians of the Internet. Yale University Press
  9. Hardt, M., & Negri, A. (2004). Multitude. Penguin
  10. Sontag, S. (2003). Regarding the Pain of Others. Farrar, Straus and Giroux
  11. https://arabic.euronews.com/video/2025/10/27/palestinians-gather-amid-the-rubble-to-watch-the-film-the-voice-of-hind-rajabhttps://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/may/30/all-eyes-on-rafah-how-ai-generated-image-spread-across-social-media
  • Support Shuddhashar

    Support our independent work, help us to stay pay-wall free by becoming a patron today.

    Join Patreon

Subscribe to Shuddhashar FreeVoice to receive updates

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Shuddhashar FreeVoice to receive updates

শুদ্ধস্বর
error: Content is protected !!