Issue 34, Intimacy

Intimacy is one of those taken-for-granted terms, a vague concept that most of us think we understand and don’t need to define. In actuality, the concept of intimacy evokes varied and contradictory emotions, complicated by its intersection with personal histories, memories, desires, and ideologies. When embedded in amorous privacy, intimacy conveys feelings of closeness, relatedness, and of caring and being cared for. Encapsulated in a feeling, a relationship, an atmosphere, or a moment, intimacy is pleasurable and deeply nurturing for humanity and the human heart. In these ways, intimacy is intertwined with trust, enhancing our lives and feelings of connectedness. With intimate relationships, we feel less isolated in our daily lives; we feel like we belong, like what we do and who we are matters.
Even so, for some people and at some times, intimacy is violent and traumatizing.  State and military policies have repeatedly been shown to weaponized intimacy, sometimes through campaigns that include sexual assault and rape, and often by turning a blind eye. Take, for example, how “honor” killings that target a coupling between two lovers of different religions or castes are systematically ignored or explained away; or how hundreds of migrant women get intimately abused every week as they travel from Latin America to the U.S.-Mexico border; or how prison officials use sexual abuse as a form of torture in some prisons around the globe; or the frequent incidents of sexual abuse of youth by trusted priests.  One may think of these occurrences as individual acts of violence, or as cultural or historical aberrations.  However, history reveals how intimate violence can be systemic, with broader societal and global factors that perpetuate the intimate abuse of people. In our modern day and in the past, communities that are persecuted, excluded, targeted, or exiled are acutely affected by intimate violence.
Intimate violence can also be entwined in relationships among peers – in domestic violence, a toxic relationship, or sexual assault in college campuses. In these and all examples, intimate violence can be a physical or an emotional act; it is often both. We see this in cases of domestic abuse, where an individual is both physically and emotionally tortured, yet unable to imagine ending the relationship. These experiences not only taint that relationships with fear, rage, and isolation, but they also have long lasting impacts on other and future relationships.
So, how is intimacy weaponized? How are issues connected to intimacy surveilled by totalitarian states and fundamentalist groups? How does the state perpetuate cases of intimate violence differently depending on people’s identities?
Time and again, heads of states, governments, and community organizations have controlled certain aspects of intimacy, blurring the lines between private domain and what is considered public. Around the world, states intrude on our most intimate spaces by erecting laws limiting whom we can love, with whom we can have sex, and what we do with our own bodies. Although these forms of intimate violence differ from explicitly brutal forms like rape, the state’s intrusion into our private intimate lives reveal a telling story about which people matter, and which people can be subjected to state control. In some countries, including the United States and Poland, the private spaces of women’s bodies are controlled by the state with access to abortions severely restricted – even if the pregnancy was caused by intimate violence – and the menstrual cycles of young women surveilled by state actors. Nearly 69 countries have prohibitions on same sex love, sometimes with draconian punishments including “conversion therapies” or even death. Bodies that do not conform to a standardized binary are subject to examination by doctors and lawyers to determine which bathroom a person can use, which sports team they can join, and whether they have access to life-saving healthcare.
Yet, against all odds, people resist. When authoritarian and fundamentalist forces penetrate the sacred private sphere, tear down communities, condemn gestures of love, people rise up. Some risk everything by crossing the Mediterranean in search of a place they can call home, where they can express themselves without fear or find a job so they can support their family. Others go to the streets to demand rights that should have been theirs to begin with or to protest patriarchy’s control over their lives, education, marriages, and bodies.
When people are struggling, positive intimate relationships can be healing and nurturing. For marginalized or threatened communities, a caring intimate relationship can be incredibly meaningful, shining light within a landscape of hardship and offering individuals a sense of agency and direction. Consider the experience of a migrant family finding a welcoming community as they resettle; a child at a refugee camp forming a close-knit relationship with another child they can trust; or an exiled writer having the freedom to speak their truest opinions and thoughts, allowing them to re-create an intimate relationship with the self. Consider learning how to nurture and love yourself and your own body, despite years of social and political scrutiny and abuse about the color of your skin or your gendered clothing choices.
Intimacy is also embedded in the simplest acts, entangled in the rhythm of everyday life: a kiss, an embrace, interlocked hands, a kind deed; a parent caring for their children; a family snuggled around the fireplace on a cold, wintry evening; the interspecies bonds of care and affection; the sharing of food whether from the same plate, the exchange of a piece of wedding cake between newlyweds, or the offering of paan as a token of love. Intimate encounters may be fleeting, but they can offer hope and meaning when life feels especially difficult.
Despite the concept’s broad parameters, its personal impact is deep, and commonly encompasses profound and memorable experiences. There is also an air of secrecy in intimacy – an expression and experience that is shared with only a few, that occurs only in proximity, and that is deeply personal and private.
This issue of Shuddhashar takes a critical look at intimacy in its myriad forms and considers how it affects communities and individuals both positively and negatively. We hope these multifaceted descriptions of intimacy will inspire you to notice how the concept is interwoven in your personal life and the lives of others.

Understanding Intimacy: Between Joys and Frailty

An epochal issue Intimacy is a defining fact of our times. The beginnings of the 20th century were marked by the spread and recognition of a public sphere born from the emerging institutions of first modernity (free market, the nation state, and modernist urbanity). Later, a landmark of modern societies has been the rise of …

Understanding Intimacy: Between Joys and Frailty Read More »

Thinking Structurally about Sexual Violence: The Limits of Consent

The persistent nature of sexual violence and harm has become one of the great preoccupations of the past twenty years. For all this public attention, however, there is a remarkable level of equanimity about potential solutions. Regardless of the precise manifestation of harm, we turn to consent, which is frequently characterised as ‘everything’ when it …

Thinking Structurally about Sexual Violence: The Limits of Consent Read More »

Sex Work, Sex Wars, and the Intimacies of the US/Mexico Relationship

I first saw the films of Don Anahí in 2021, projected on the rooftop of Casa Gomorra, a queer living space that also hosts parties and workshops while conducting anthropological fieldwork about pleasure activism among LGBTQI+ people in Mexico City. During the pandemic, Casa Gomorra residents started selling pizza one day a week on their …

Sex Work, Sex Wars, and the Intimacies of the US/Mexico Relationship Read More »

Free Speech/Intimate Threat: When the Proud Boys Come to Campus

On Oct 24, 2022, a group of far-right agitators dressed in all black harassed and assaulted Penn State student demonstrators. The students were protesting the arrival of Gavin McInnes, founder of the Proud Boys, and Alex Stein, another far-right actor, who were invited speakers by another student group Uncensored America, a pro-free speech organization. To …

Free Speech/Intimate Threat: When the Proud Boys Come to Campus Read More »

Learning the Languages of Intimacy: Changing Modes and Moods in Sweden

In his recent book, Metropolitan Intimacies: An Ethnography on the Poetics of Daily Life, Francisco Cruces (2022) explores how urbanites in Madrid, Montevideo and Mexico City handle intimacy in their social life. It is a rich ethnography of everyday activities and a fascinating analysis of how intimacy has become such a central theme in contemporary …

Learning the Languages of Intimacy: Changing Modes and Moods in Sweden Read More »

Proximity and Intimacy in the Lives of Pavement Dwellers in Mumbai

Along many of the tree-lined side streets that radiate away from one of Mumbai’s main railways stations are rows of tiny, painstakingly assembled dwellings perched on the pavement, a hairs breadth away from swiftly moving vehicular traffic. Some of the dwellings are two storeys high, fabricated from bits of corrugated metal sheets typically used for …

Proximity and Intimacy in the Lives of Pavement Dwellers in Mumbai Read More »

The Chronicles of Lip Syncing: Tom Holland, Masculinity, and Me

When I have had the pleasure of writing for Shuddhashar and similar publications in the past, my reflections have tended to veer towards analytical and academic essays. In a world as complex and structurally inequitable as the one we live in, it felt important for me to write critical pieces that built on my experiences …

The Chronicles of Lip Syncing: Tom Holland, Masculinity, and Me Read More »

Physical Biographies: Sensations of the Moving Body

When Listening Is Hard to Hear The voice of my body, once almost inaudible, grew to the pitch of a hospital siren when we were trying to conceive. I didn’t know how to mute the voice that spoke of every motion in my womb, the different scent of sweat approaching my menstrual cycle, the sharp …

Physical Biographies: Sensations of the Moving Body Read More »

Polyamorous Intimacy in Populist Pandemonium

In the shadow of the overturning of Roe v. Wade, there lie questions in the U.S. concerning the populist demonization of particular relationship styles, sexual orientations, and social choices, restricting types of family formation and reproduction. The impact of Roe on family formations suggests that the next few years will be critical to determining who …

Polyamorous Intimacy in Populist Pandemonium Read More »

Private Love, Public Eyes: Media, Family, and Honour Killings in India | Nandhitha Babuji

Intimacy is often invoked as a private manner. It is the private emotions shared between two individuals, often cemented by affection and love. But sometimes, intimacies of certain ‘sorts’ seem to take centre stage in public discussions. People seem to have a say in these intimacies wherein boundaries of privacy are overlooked and crossed. This …

Private Love, Public Eyes: Media, Family, and Honour Killings in India | Nandhitha Babuji Read More »

error: Content is protected !!