The Eye of/on the Storm: Climatological Surveillance in British India

Share this:

Climatological surveillance positioned India within an imperial surveillance network where it is distinctive in its climate and behaviour yet linked with other parts of the world, producing a solidarity of the empire and a solidarity around climate.

At a time when imperial expansion and imperial science were mapping and organizing the world, making the world knowable in a universalistic worldview, British attention to meteorological conditions in and around the subcontinent was inflected by anxiety over the climatological vulnerability of Europeans and their ships headed towards or residing in the tropics (Adas 1989, Chakraborty 1999). The meteorological sciences (and the sciences of earthquakes and geology) were consolidated by the colonial state in the colony, and the colonial state was, in turn, consolidated by the science because it organized the region into an observable terrain (Roy 2010: 8).

For example, on the first page of J.E. Gastrell and Henry F. Blanford’s Report on the Calcutta Cyclone of the 5th October 1864 (1866), they provide a table of wind direction for the five days preceding the cyclone, from Kandy (Ceylon), Port Blair, Madras, Chittagong, Cuttack, Calcutta, Cachar, and this is followed by barometric and thermometer readings for these places (1–3). In the same volume, the Appendix is made of logs from various ships that were in the Bay during the storm. J. Elliott, in Report of the Vizag and Backergunj Cyclones of October 1876 (1877), compiles data received from the ‘private observatory of Mr. A. V. Nursingrow’ (38, 48 and elsewhere).

It was expected that knowledge-making was to be reliable and codified, and not all sources of information were to be trusted. Henry Blanford embodies a discourse of knowability when he states that ‘violent storms’ and ‘similar local disturbances’ may be ‘rare and exceptional’, but these do not catch the observers ‘unawares’ because they ‘can tell beforehand what is the numerical probability of a storm in any given month’. With the help of technological apparatuses such as the telegraph, Blanford continues, the British observers and climatologists can ‘watch their [cyclones’] generation and growth, their decay and final extinction, all within the area of our possessions and their included seas’.

He concludes by pronouncing: ‘order and regularity are as prominent characteristics of our atmospheric phenomena, as are apparent caprice and uncertainty those of their European counterparts’ (144). In a footnote, he adds: ‘Were there a telegraph line to Port Blair and the Nicobars, and one to False Point, it would be almost impossible for a cyclone to be formed (except, perhaps, in the south-west or extreme south of the Bay) without our knowledge’ (144).

Blanford asserts complete certainty over the subcontinent’s climatic conditions: for the weather to change suddenly and without the observers being aware, he declares, is ‘impossible’. Everything about the weather in the subcontinent and its vicinity, he says, is marked by ‘order and regularity’ (144). Echoing Blanford is John Eliot in his Hand-Book of Cyclonic Storms in the Bay of Bengal for the Use of Sailors, where he points to the possibility, indeed necessity, of knowing, managing and predicting cyclones through the collation and interpretation of storm data even as he expresses dissatisfaction that the sailors, who ought to be more interested with the weather patterns, continue to rely naively on ‘upon sky and weather indications’ rather than the ‘more exact methods of modern meteorologists’  (1900: 29).

British memoirs, reports and commentaries on cyclones and earthquakes constitute imperial disaster knowledge cultures, which were marked by the rise and spread of disaster observational regimes made possible through a network of scientists, journalists, and even untrained observers on the ground. In the process, the regimes constructed India as a natural laboratory and subject to climatological surveillance that then enabled solidarity across different climatic zones and regions, particularly the water bodies.

Observing India

‘Observation’, preferably uniform and standardized, that collated data from a large network of experts but also untrained observers, was an integral part of the imperial mineralogical, anthropological, meteorological and botanical sciences in the nineteenth century (Chakrabarti 2020, Endersby 2008, Cullen and Geros 2020).

Observation and data collection were integral to the imperial project, and Blanford makes this abundantly clear: ‘There still remains a vast area of the British possessions, respecting the meteorology of which our knowledge is extremely scanty’ (260). Many of the lacunae in meteorological knowledge, Blanford argues, could be addressed through state intervention, including ‘regularly kept registers of the Government observatories’ (261).

Henry Blanford opens his account with the statement:

The object of meteorological observation is to collect facts for studying the physical changes of the atmosphere, in order that we may gain therefrom a knowledge of their causes and their laws. (1)

Observational regimes linked experiential-observer surveillance accounts with the experimental, where the former was situated within the natural laboratory of the subcontinent, and the latter could be on ships (where sailors learnt to operate the instruments) or laboratories elsewhere, thus creating a vast network of observers, observatories, experimentalists and sufferer eyewitnesses.

Climatological surveillance positioned India as distinctive in its climatological and behaviour and yet resonant with, connected to and reminiscent of, events both past and present from around the world, and looking forward to the recurrence of similar behaviour from the climate in the future. The observational regime, therefore, places India outside the boundaries of the already studied and known world and on the same plane as the known world. The observational regime encoded in the disaster memoir moves constantly between locality and the world, between the histories of storms and and the future (recurrence) of cyclones.

Colonialism’s disaster knowledge culture underlined the endemic nature of disaster in the subcontinent or ‘disaster endemism’, where disaster is endemic to and defines the place, and the subcontinent is a crisis-prone region (Arnold 1999). It also assumed and perceived the subcontinent as a ‘natural laboratory’ (Cullen and Geros 2020: 12) in which the peculiarities of atmospheric and geological phenomena could be explored.

Henry Blanford writes that India seems to be an unusually suitable laboratory for observing such phenomena: ‘India, together with the circumjacent seas, is, in the main, a secluded and independent arena of atmospheric action … having peculiarities of its own’ (144). Blanford isolates India from the rest of Asia: ‘We have a field of study, second in interest to none in the whole range of meteorological science’ (145). And later: ‘the diurnal oscillation of pressure, which is nowhere exhibited with more intensity and with more marked phases of variation than in India’ (185, and elsewhere).

India can, with all its peculiarities, further the science itself, Blanford claims, especially in subdomains such as atmospheric heat absorption. With such a move, India has, of course, been spotlighted as a peculiar space that can enable science to acquire new dimensions of understanding and methodology. The eye of the storm is matched by an eye on it, an eye that is also simultaneously monitoring the subcontinent.

While Blanford is making a case for climate exceptionalism, the positioning of the subcontinent as a natural laboratory under the imperial observational regime, more often than not, linked it with the other parts of the world. The observational regime rendered the cyclones and earthquakes of the subcontinent ‘collective and connective significance’ (Grove 1997: 125). This meant the phenomena observed on the subcontinent could be linked to phenomena elsewhere, making the ‘significance’ both translocal and transnational. The scientific surveillance regimes cut across geographical zones locally and are connected to similar instances and climatological-geological phenomena worldwide.

Bringing together different sites of observation required the creation of a network of observers and observatories, as well as the systematic bringing together of the data collected. This took two forms: the linkage of places and linkages across time, producing a solidarity of the empire and a solidarity around climate.

‘Climatological Solidarity’

Although its weather may set India apart but well within the English modes of climatological monitoring and documentation, the observational regime needs to be systematically expanded into all corners of their possessions in what John Eliot’s Climatological Atlas of India (1904) termed ‘climatological solidarity’ (cited in Cullen and Geros 2020: 3).

Colonial disaster networks were made up of observers geographically distributed through the exchange of information and, finally, in the form of the data sheets and maps that generate climatological-geological solidarity. In the network, there is the professional scientist who examines and interprets the data received, and the sailor or eyewitness is one of several independent correspondents. There is, therefore, a hierarchy in place where the correspondents serve the order.

Climatological surveillance networks often co-opted native observers. Then there was the evidence of what Henry Blanford in his Indian Meteorologist’s Vade Mecum (1877) termed ‘eyewitness and sufferer’ (229). There were sailors tasked with observation and recording of barometers and wind direction, and there were professionals like Blanford. Long-term observations and simultaneity of observations had to be made. They would be localized at once, and yet beyond geopolitical borders, they would provide historical accounts and record present disasters in order to manage disasters in the future.

A network is ‘a set of positions within which an object … has meaning, it is clear that the facticity of an object is relative only to a particular network or networks’ (Latour and Woolgar 107). The creation of linked meteorological and seismological observatories, protocols of information-gathering, distributed witnessing modes and observational regimes, and the textual archive at the end of the process enabled the mapping of the ‘natural’ vulnerabilities of the subcontinent, underlined the disaster endemism of the region and created meanings of the event of the cyclone or the earthquake.

In the climatological surveillance network that comes into being, first in a fragmented fashion and later more formally with the setting up of the Indian Meteorological Department, the key elements are the observers and the observational regimes. There is no ‘summit view’ although there is an ‘integrated vision’ of the disaster in the colonial writings (Secord 401-2). There is no single observer but rather a state of networked and collaborative witnessing in these narratives. The integrated vision comes from distributed witnessing and the supplementing of eyewitness accounts with a vast textual apparatus.

For cyclones, observations were sought from land-based observers and ships at different geographical points, and the tables in, say, Gastrell and Blanford’s accounts. The latitudes and longitudes of each vessel and land observation point were recorded, noted and linked to barometric and thermometric readings (19, and elsewhere). The ships, therefore, were themselves surveying devices and mobile laboratories. Native observations of atmospheric phenomena were also communicated to the English officers/scientists and duly recorded, albeit without naming the native informants (Gastrell and Blanford 93).

While the natural laboratory was clearly networked translocally and even transnationally, as the above instances show, the network was also operationalized across time zones (transtemporal). The recording of data from different observatories and observers, collating reports by eyewitnesses and rescue operations officers, and scientists tasked with studies of seismological activity are, given the nature of the events, translocal.

The accounts call for both simultaneity and long-term observation of weather patterns. The simultaneity of reportage from numerous places, including far-flung places like Edinburgh, produces a synchronicity of disaster. Blanford indeed calls for what he terms ‘synoptic observations’. He defines this as ‘obtain[ing] observations made at the same absolute time, irrespective of the local time, all over the world’ (63).

That is, the weather would be observed at the same predetermined hour in different parts of the world: say, 11 AM in the subcontinent and its exact equivalent local time in Europe, the Caribbean and East Asia. To this end, he furnishes a table of local time zones (63–4). He insists: ‘the value of the results is in many cases less rigorously dependent on the continuity of the record’ (261).

The network puts long-term observational regimes in place, thereby studying disaster over a period of time and contributing to the disaster endemism discourse. Documenting the history of cyclones in the subcontinent, Blanford writes how he compiled notices and reports of ‘115 cyclones in the Bay of Bengal’ (1877: 246). Then follows a monthly list, with dates, of cyclonic activity.

Blanford, outlining his method, writes: ‘every case in which a storm has been formed in the last days of one month and has lasted into the beginning of the following month, has been reckoned to the month in which the storm was generated’ (246–7). A long-term and translocal documentation of atmospheric conditions such as solar radiation is required, Blanford writes (159).

Eliot, likewise, gives monthly records of pressure and winds every season (71, 90, 94–5, and elsewhere). Eliot also lists what he terms ‘noteworthy disasters’ of the last fifteen years in the Indian seas, which includes accounts from the Arabian Sea, the Indian Ocean and the Bay of Bengal (3–4). Eliot concludes that ‘the dangers are hence as great and real now as they were a hundred and fifty years ago when much less was known of their character’, thus gesturing toward both synchronic/simultaneous and diachronic/historical accounts of climatological science and activity (4).

Piddington concludes his narrative by arguing that governments should ‘organize some system for collecting, registering and digesting the vast masses of scattered information which already exist, and which are, from the countless ships of England, America, and France alone, hourly accumulating and passing into oblivion’ (378). Henry Blanford, while insisting that local conditions must be recorded, also states: ‘this occurrence of the cloud minimum some hours after sunset seems to be a general, and not merely a local law’ (111). He has already stated, just prior to this comment:

In order that our observations may be intelligently made, we must have some clear idea of the purposes they are intended to subserve, and it is to be feared that few persons, even of those who have a real liking for the work, at present aim at much more than preserving a record of how much one season is hotter or wetter than another, or of gaining some knowledge of the characteristics of the local climate as it affects health, agriculture, and other immediate conditions of well-being. (100)

Thus, while local conditions are to be studied for the purposes of understanding ‘immediate conditions of well-being’, these are more important for how they contribute to the larger understanding of science. The local must necessarily be effaced in favour of generic principles.

India is subject to a certain observational time, measured in the tables and lists of earthquakes and cyclones, the shifts of temperature and pressure, all of which recast the subcontinent into a different order of time, one determined by the imperial observer. Eliot insists that the data is for both the present and the future: ‘certain and definite information from which to infer the present and probable future general character of the weather, so far as it can be determined by its use’ (29).

One should be able to, writes Eliot, ‘forecast their [storms’] probable future line of march and changes’ (50). Later, he computes the odds for the cyclonic storms likely in the Bay of Bengal at ‘seven to one’ (67). The current data, Eliot suggests, would hold good in the future, and atmospheric changes in any future storm would be in line with what has been observed now. Here, Eliot’s observations and suggestions orient the narrative towards the future, addressing the need to ensure the absence of continuity between the present disaster and the future. Here, Eliot fits his narrative into a conventional vulnerability narrative, which imagines future possibilities but over which one needs to assert at least some measure of control.

*

Climatological surveillance positioned India as distinctive in its climatological and behaviour and yet resonant with, connected to and reminiscent of, events both past and present from around the world, and looking forward to the recurrence of similar behaviour from the climate in the future. The observational regime, therefore, places India outside the boundaries of the already studied and known world and on the same plane as the known world. The observational regime encoded in the disaster memoir moves constantly between locality and the world, between the histories of storms and the future (recurrence) of cyclones.

Climatological solidarity firmly placed India within the imperial surveillance network that ranged from Scotland to the Caribbean to the Bay of Bengal. Monitoring the storm enabled the placing of the meteorological eye on the conquests of the empire.

 

References:

Adas, M. (1989). Machines as the Measure of Men: Science, Technology, and Ideologies of Western Dominance. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.

Arnold, D. (1999). ‘Hunger in the Garden of Plenty: The Bengal Famine of 1770’. In Johns (ed) Dreadful Visitations: Confronting Natural Disaster in the Age of Enlightenment. London and New York: Routledge.

Arnold, D. (2006). The Tropics and the Traveling Gaze: India, Landscape, and Science, 1800–1856. Seattle: University of Washington Press.

Aubin, D, C. Bigg and H. O. Sibum. (2010) ‘Introduction: Observatory Techniques in Nineteenth-Century Science and Society’. In Aubin, Bigg and Sibum (eds) The Heavens on Earth: Observatories and Astronomy in Nineteenth-Century Science and Culture. Durham and London: Duke University Press.

Blanford, H. F. (1877). The Indian Meteorologist’s Vade Mecum. Calcutta: Thacker & Spink.

Chakrabarti, P. (1999) ‘The Asiatic society and its vision of science: metropolitan knowledge in a colonial world’. Calcutta Historical Journal 21-22: 1-32.

—. (2020). Inscriptions of Nature: Geology and the Naturalization of Antiquity. Baltimore: `s Hopkins University Press.

Cullen, B. and  C.L. Geros. (2010). ‘Constructing the Monsoon: Colonial Meteorological Cartography, 1844-1944’. History of Meteorology 9: 1-26.

Cushman, G.T. (2013). ‘The imperial politics of hurricane prediction: from Calcutta and Havana to Manila and Galveston, 1839-1900’. In Erika Marie Bsumek,  David Kinkela and Mark Atwood Lawrence (eds) Nation-States and the Global Environment. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 137-162.

Eliot, J. (1900). Hand-book of Cyclonic Storms in the Bay of Bengal. Calcutta: Superintendent of Government Printing. 2 vols. [Vol. 1: Text, Vol. 2: Plates]

Elliott, J. (1877). Report of the Vizag and Backergunj Cyclones of October 1876. Calcutta: Bengal Secretariat Press.

Endersby, J. (2008). Imperial Nature: Joseph Hooker and the Practices of Victorian Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Gastrell, J.E. and H.F. Blanford. (1866). Report on the Calcutta Cyclone of the 5th October 1864. Calcutta: OT Cutter, Military Orphan Press.

Grove, R. (1977). Ecology, Climate and Empire: Colonialism and Global Environmental History, 1400-1940. Cambridge: White Horse Press.

Latour, B. and S. Woolgar. (1979). Laboratory Life: The Construction of Scientific Facts. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Piddington, H. (1864) The Sailor’s Horn-book for the Law of Storms. London: Williams and Norgate. 4th ed.

Roy, T. (2010). ‘ “The Law of Storms”: European and Indigenous Responses to Natural Disasters in Colonial India, C.1800–1850’. Australian Economic History Review 50.1: 6-22.

Secord, J. (2018). ‘Global geology and the tectonics of empire’. In H. A. Curry, N. Jardine, J.A. Secord and E. C. Spary (eds) Worlds of Natural History. Cambridge University Press. 401-418.

  • Support Shuddhashar

    Support our independent work, help us to stay pay-wall free by becoming a patron today.

    Join Patreon

Subscribe to Shuddhashar FreeVoice to receive updates

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Shuddhashar FreeVoice to receive updates

শুদ্ধস্বর
error: Content is protected !!