Calling something backlash assigns a reactive nature to the target, reducing an incredibly nuanced and intricate position to a black-and-white issue.
Traditionally, vaccine hesitancy is viewed as backlash against science. In this essay, I argue that “backlash” is a label assigned from a point of view rather than an inherent quality of the subject, and that when policy absorbs what it once dismissed, the label becomes something else.
The COVID-19 vaccine was the fastest vaccine developed in human history, taking under a year to develop, test, and deploy. My mother was hesitant to give this vaccine to my sisters and me, nervous about how quickly this novel technology was produced. Throughout her life, she focused on intellectualizing situations, planning three steps ahead, and using logic, not emotion, in her decision-making. To her and many others, the vaccine seemed like a promising way to ease the fear and panic the pandemic had induced, but logically, it seemed hastily made and inadequately tested.
At the time, these beliefs seemed disruptive. Why would a person not choose to get vaccinated and help the world return to normal? This caution registered as backlash against scientific discovery and societal norms: something necessary to overcome, but not to understand.
Asserting that something is backlash assigns a reactive nature to the target. Reactivity is often attributed as a response rather than a position, rash rather than reasoned. This ascription signals that backlash isn’t worth examining. The label of backlash can take an incredibly nuanced and intricate position and reduce it to a black-and-white issue, just as a dataset would reduce my mother’s hesitancy to a number.
Her reasoning deserves to be accurately expressed because the understanding usually attributed to vaccine-hesitant individuals is not the version she, and many others, held. She was not hesitant because she believed these vaccines were released untested; the trials enrolled more than 70,000 participants in total. She was hesitant because no one knew what could happen long term. For the first time in her life, she faced a decision she couldn’t plan or prepare for, and the thought of harming her kids was grave.
After learning of a COVID-19 vaccine shortage in my local area, my mother immediately drove my oldest sister over two hours away to get vaccinated. This decision was not made lightly, and the cognitive dissonance she experienced was tremendous. Nothing about her assessment of the situation had changed. Nobody had given her more information about the vaccine’s long-term effects, and if you had asked her that evening about the speed of development, she would have remained resolute in her belief that it was developed too fast. What changed was availability: scarcity accomplished in one day what months of public messaging had failed to do. When the vaccine became mandated for various events, we all got vaccinated so my family could return to normal life.
I thought deeply about the sequence of these events: my mother, so deeply hesitant, acted against her own beliefs because of scarcity. If the hesitancy was due to missing facts, more information would have resolved it. But the information she needed did not exist yet. If this hesitancy were a fixed conviction, a vaccine shortage would not have moved it. It was neither of these; instead, it was a reasonable judgment made within specific circumstances. When these circumstances shifted, the decision shifted too, yet the belief stayed exactly where it was. This insight intrigued me and became the origin of a multi-study quantitative research program on vaccine hesitancy and how it interacts with scarcity, social norms, and mandates.
At Stanford, I was certain I wanted to write an honors thesis: it seemed like the perfect culmination of my ongoing vaccine hesitancy research. I excitedly proposed an additional quantitative research proposal to the Honors Director. She managed to broaden my perspective with a single observation:
“Quantitative research, although important, can be so minimizing. People are more than binary numbers in a numerical dataset.”
I internalized this perspective. If my mother were to be categorized numerically, she would be a 1 instead of a 0 for being vaccine hesitant. However, my mother was more than a number: her hesitancy was nuanced and logically thought through; her “backlash” had its own reasoning.
Research, while helping humans achieve incredible breakthroughs, is inherently limited in its design. Quantitative measures are designed to capture the magnitude of a person’s characteristic, not the logic behind it. A Likert scale can measure only the degree of a participant’s vaccine hesitancy, but it tells the researcher nothing about the negative experience in the doctor’s office or the fear of hurting one’s children that contributed to that hesitancy. When a participant has a high hesitancy score, this finding usually reflects the individual, not the object or institution the participant is rating. Thus, the objectivity of backlash begins to falter.
I reworked my proposal to focus on individuals’ lived experiences. After winning Stanford’s Major Grant, I traveled across the United States to see how different ideologies manifest across geographies and how backlash looks in different regions.
Forty interviews were conducted in five states that varied in hesitancy, majority political alignment, and geographical region. Finding individuals to interview was not easy: over the years, vaccines had become polarizing, almost taboo to discuss. People became afraid to share opinions that went against the norm of vaccinating, or, in some regions, the norm of not vaccinating.
A quantitative study involving these forty individuals would have produced a distribution. However, what participants described in these interviews is something a distribution cannot capture. One pattern that stood out was how the mandate was presented. Some workplaces focused on mitigating the spread through teamwork and ensuring employees played their part, while others made demands and threatened employees. While the presentation mattered less for non-hesitant individuals, aggressive mandate enforcement made hesitant individuals feel threatened rather than encouraged and, in some cases, furthered their hesitancy.
Some interviewees feared backlash for non-compliance. Specifically, a man in Louisiana was the sole provider for his household and could not afford to lose his job, forcing him to comply against his beliefs. A healthcare worker in Montana found that using an exemption to avoid compliance with the mandate led to scrutiny, isolation from her coworkers, and even harassment from hospital higher-ups.
A laborer in Ohio was seen as a trailblazer for refusing vaccination, and his coworkers banded together to protect him from losing his job. The healthcare worker and laborer both refused the vaccine; however, one was celebrated, and the other was isolated. Each experience shows how backlash can affect an individual and that mandate policies do not produce a uniform response; instead, the response depends on an individual’s resources and the environment he or she happens to be in.
Across the United States, participants’ hesitancy reflected less a belief about immunology than a discussion of bodily autonomy. Institutional mandates imposed control over an individual’s body, threatening the freedom so many social movements had fought to gain. Those who refused the mandate kept their control but gained a label. These labels signaled backlash, assigning reactivity rather than reasoning. In turn, this labeling generated backlash against those who bore the label, perpetuating negative consequences.
Norms, which are collectively decided on, help dictate what is socially appropriate in society. Mandate policies go a step further. Often, policies and norms align, but sometimes they do not. This clash splits backlash into two categories: social and policy backlash. Each type of backlash presents itself differently. My mother faced the social kind. No law or institution required her to vaccinate her children; however, she faced neighbors’ judgment, accusations of ignorance, and the heavy question of why she wouldn’t do her part to help get back to normal.
The people I interviewed, however, often faced not only social but also policy backlash, including threats of job loss. The distinction matters. Policy requirements demand compliance and behavioral change; however, people’s original beliefs often persist. Social judgment is different in that it does not demand an action, but is more likely to shift a person’s belief.
Social backlash can precede, outlast, or run opposite to policy backlash, and either can shift without the other following. During the pandemic, the policy and social norms pointed in the same direction. Mandates became prevalent, and norms shifted toward vaccination; thus, my mother stood at the intersection, opposing both. However, policy changes can turn what was once deemed backlash into an institutionally supported view. In June 2025, the Secretary of Health and Human Services dismissed all seventeen members of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. In January 2026, a schedule assembled without the committee cut the universally recommended vaccinations from 18 to 11. In August 2026, Florida proposed to remove four vaccines from its school entry requirements.
Each of these changes was seemingly made for hesitant parents. These federal recommendations now align more with her original position than with the one she was socially pressured to hold. Socially, however, in many of the areas that I visited, she would still face backlash against her hesitancy.
Her belief never changed: the resistance to her position has softened institutionally, but not socially. Her situation precisely demonstrates that backlash is assigned, not absolute. My mother had her doubts, but she didn’t disbelieve. She just wanted five years of data that did not exist. This new policy offers fewer vaccines and less evidence than before, not more, which is not what she or other concerned parents seemed to be seeking. Her hesitancy and others’ stances were useful to policy-makers; however, the response did not adequately address their reasoning or the lack of research.
Asserting that something is backlash assigns a reactive nature to the target. Reactivity is often attributed as a response rather than a position, rash rather than reasoned. This ascription signals that backlash isn’t worth examining. The label of backlash can take an incredibly nuanced and intricate position and reduce it to a black-and-white issue, just as a dataset would reduce my mother’s hesitancy to a number.
Somewhere in a large dataset, my mother is categorized as a 1. This number is accurate: she experienced hesitancy, and it rightfully records that. It does not, however, record the two-hour drive she made, the hours of research she conducted, or the jigsaw puzzle with missing pieces she so desperately tried to solve. It was never designed to; its sole purpose was to classify her action as backlash rather than understanding it. Understanding the reasons for backlash can be critical to addressing it.
What does calling something backlash allow us to avoid?
Image: Hayley Tschetter/Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)
