Trump’s support for Iranian protesters reveals a tragedy where desperation leads the powerless to believe they must comply when powerful men expect their backs scratched.
It was January 2026. The internet was down, the streets were still raw from bloodshed, and we were shouting at each other about Iran’s future. “I’m sick of it,” Hossein snapped, using a sexual metaphor so blunt it silenced the table. If we were going to be abused by the new government, he meant, it might as well be a different one.
For a moment, I wanted to reach across the table and hug him — not because I agreed, but because I recognized the sheer desperation beneath the anger. That desperation was evident in many accounts circulating online at the time. On January 5, 2026, for example, Asoo published testimonies from Iranian teachers describing the protests. One comment captures the atmosphere starkly: “One of my [students] told me I wanted to attempt suicide the other day. I had nothing to lose; now that the protests have begun, let me give up my life for Iran’s future”.[1]
On Friday night, January 9, 2026, while the internet blackout was still in place, my sister and I — anxious and exhausted — watched Iran International to learn what had happened in other cities and how violent the demonstrations had become. The channel offered mostly conjecture and fragmentary reports. What appeared repeatedly in the available footage were Lion-and-Sun flags and chants of “Long Live the Shah” or “This is the final battle; Pahlavi will return”—images and slogans the channel seemed particularly keen to foreground.
Then Reza Pahlavi appeared. As he spoke, he appeared to be reading from a text positioned behind the camera, urging Iranians to remain in the streets the following night and to seize key locations. He concluded by saying he was “preparing to return.”
This mixture of nostalgia — embodied in Pahlavi’s image — and the promise of “transition” persuaded a substantial segment of society to embrace a familiar claim: that there was no viable alternative to him. Setting aside the political reality of such a narrative, one can examine his conduct during those deadly days. One morning, amid the blackout and the suspension of calls and messaging — after many people had already been killed — authorities reportedly sent mass text messages warning that “terrorist groups” were among the protesters and urging parents to monitor their children. Based on previous uprisings, the implication was clear: a violent crackdown was likely imminent.
It is really painful to see how some Iranians now discuss the grandeur of B-2 bombers or the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln, deployed to the Persian Gulf, as symbols of possible salvation rather than retaliation or preemptive protection. But not all Iranians forget the thousands of lives lost in Israeli military operations during the recent twelve-day war, nor the trauma associated with the much-celebrated B-2 bombers — described by Benjamin Netanyahu as “big” and “beautiful.”
In such circumstances, a prudent political figure might have suspended calls for further street protests or sought alternative forms of mobilization to reduce the risk to civilians. It is reasonable to expect someone claiming allegiance to secular democracy to avoid offering false hope — or encouraging actions whose human cost was painfully predictable. Instead, Pahlavi urged people to continue and renewed promises of his return.
Yet, like his father, his political prospects remain closely tied to support networks outside Iran, particularly in the United States. To his evident disappointment, Donald Trump told Reuters: “He seems very nice, but I don’t know how he’d play within his own country”.[2]
Speaking with characteristic bravado, Trump has also expressed support for Iranian protesters while warning the Islamic Republic against killing them. Some supporters interpret these statements at face value, overlooking the broader strategic interests that typically shape U.S. foreign policy in the region. They have scratched Trump’s back and are waiting for him to scratch theirs. But Trump’s support for protesters is paternalistic in a deeper psychological sense.
In Escape from Freedom (1941), Erich Fromm explores the psychological dynamics of dependency and domination in political leadership. He highlights three kinds of sadistic tendencies. One involves creating dependence — establishing absolute and unrestricted power over others so that they become instruments of the leader’s will, “clay in the potter’s hand”, rather than autonomous actors.
A second consists of exploitation: the desire not only to dominate but to use others for one’s own purposes, extracting material or immaterial value from them, including their loyalty, emotional energy, or symbolic legitimacy. A third tendency is the impulse to inflict suffering or to witness it — often not through direct physical harm but through humiliation, anxiety, or psychological pressure.
Fromm also emphasizes that such tendencies are rarely recognized openly by those who embody them. Instead, they are commonly masked by narratives of benevolence, protection, or moral superiority. Authority may be justified through claims of superior knowledge — that obedience is required for the subordinate’s own good — or through assertions of exceptional virtue that supposedly entitle the leader to loyalty and dependence.
Exploitation, in turn, is frequently rationalized as deserved compensation: having “done so much” for others, the authority figure claims the right to take what they want in return. More aggressive impulses are often framed defensively, as retaliation for past injuries or as preemptive protection against perceived threats.
Based on Fromm’s framework, one can recognize elements of this sadistic dynamic in Trump’s posture toward protesters in Iran. Through years of severe sanctions, policies associated with his administration have significantly affected ordinary Iranians’ daily lives, as many struggle to make ends meet. The resulting pressure has primarily affected civilians rather than political authorities, producing widespread economic and psychological strain. In this context, the immaterial value extracted from some Iranians is loyalty born of desperation — the hope that external power might deliver change when internal avenues appear blocked.
It is really painful to see how some Iranians now discuss the grandeur of B-2 bombers or the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln, deployed to the Persian Gulf, as symbols of possible salvation rather than retaliation or preemptive protection. But not all Iranians forget the thousands of lives lost in Israeli military operations during the recent twelve-day war, nor the trauma associated with the much-celebrated B-2 bombers — described by Benjamin Netanyahu as “big” and “beautiful.”
These Iranians fundamentally reject any form of foreign intervention, particularly when it involves violence. A striking symbol of non-violent resistance was the widely circulated photograph of Farhad Meysami, his body emaciated after a prolonged hunger strike in prison. In the image, he is holding three books— The Power of the Powerless, On Tyranny, and The Narrow Corridor — with small handwritten notes attached to their covers forming a single message: “The power of powerless people against tyranny is the narrow corridor leading to freedom.”
They are also mindful of the risks inherent in rallying behind a single externally favored figure such as Reza Pahlavi. From this perspective, Pahlavi frequently speaks about democracy while acting in ways that appear inconsistent with democratic pluralism. Even after the recent bloodshed — events for which some critics hold his rhetoric partly responsible — he has continued to insist on his role as a central leader in the political transition.
He does not appear willing to relinquish his mediatized legitimacy as a leader associated with opposition mobilization. Having benefited from years of visibility on satellite channels such as Manoto and Iran International, Pahlavi has, consciously or not, contributed to the marginalization of other political activists who might also play leadership roles. The result is the familiar and exhausting refrain that there is no viable alternative to him.
What might unravel this tangled political thread in Iran? The answer remains uncertain. Iranians continue to struggle for democracy through different means. Social media, for example, is now filled with videos of funerals in which mourners dance and sing nonreligious songs beside the graves of their loved ones — acts that signal both grief and defiance.
At the same time, Trump appears to be playing both sides of the board, threatening escalation while leaving the door open for negotiation. He and other meddling paternalistic figures pursue policies that reinforce the very anti-pluralist, binary mindset that sustains cycles of domination and dependency. Many Iranians are also acutely aware that their country’s geography is not merely a national inheritance but a strategic prize — too valuable, too connected, and too consequential to be left unattended by competing powers. And so, the story continues, regardless of the immediate outcomes of political intervention.
In the end, the tragedy is not only that powerful men expect their backs scratched, but also that desperation can make the powerless believe they must comply.
Endnotes
[1] Author’s translation from Persian.
[2] Exclusive: Trump questions support for son of Iran’s last Shah inside country. By Steve Holland, January 15, 2026.
References
Fromm, E. (1941): Escape from Freedom. New York (Farrar & Rinehart).
Image Credit: “2026 protests in Neyshabur” by ماشین باز, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
